Still Just a Geek: An Annotated Memoir

Still Just a Geek: An Annotated Memoir by Wil Wheaton
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

I think this lands somewhere between 2 and 3 stars for me, sadly. I really like Wil Wheaton and love his narration in other audiobooks. I also *LOVE* Star Trek and all things geekdom so I thought this was going to be a real winner. Did I think it would get dark because of his childhood? Yes, but I was prepared for that. We almost didn't finish this audiobook and that was while being trapped in a car for a long roadtrip. Maybe that was the issue? Maybe it could have been more enjoyable broken up over long periods of time, but I would not recommend doing it back-to-back for hours at a time.

So - what was great? The anecdotes and stories at the core were great to hear. I hadn’t heard a lot of Wil Wheaton’s history in Hollywood so I learned a lot. What distracted from those bright spots was I believe mostly due to the format. The original book is based on blog posts, then there is new content layered on. The original book has footnotes, then there are new footnotes layered on top of those. All of this is surrounded by a very repetitive apology narrative. I’m not saying there isn’t original content that doesn’t a warrant an apology, but it is near constant and takes you out of the already very confusing and hard to follow layers of content.

Am I saying to just go back to his original book? No, that’s probably not the right answer either. I guess I don’t know who the target audience is for this, because I thought it was me. Maybe audiobook was the wrong format? I’m not sure and sad to have not enjoyed this one.

View all my reviews